Random Access Memories

June 29, 2013

Why do we treat mental healthcare so differently than normal healthcare?

by @ 9:03 am. Filed under Personal

So patient #1 goes to a doctor and says “I can’t smell things, flowers and food have no pleasure for me”. The doctor notices he has a broken nose that never healed right. The doctor sends him to to a plastic surgeon for Rhinoplasty to fix the problem.

Patient #2 goes to a therapist and says “I feel so alone, there is no pleasure in my life. I just don’t get along with people well.”. He is prescribed multiple Antidepressants while the doctor tries to find the right one to make the patient feel happy.

Patient #1 Really DOES have a broken nose, and a damaged sense of smell. Patient #2 Has limited social skills and needs more human contact in their life. Why is patient #2 not diagnosed correctly much less treated properly?

Opinions differ, but for me it’s a combination of several things.

#1 The drug companies are pushers. They shove new drugs onto the market looking for a band-aid simple cure, and the mental health community is happy to use it.

#2 Society doesn’t like to help people with mental or social problems. We laugh at them on TV, we avoid them in public, but they’re people too, who need help. Help that people are unwilling to give.

Dr. Des Spence, a general practitioner from Glasgow, said that “”we use antidepressants too easily, for too long, and that they are effective for few people (if at all).” Though he acknowledges that depression is real, he argued that the definition of clinical depression is too general and is “causing widespread medicalization.”

Spence also points out that antidepressant prescriptions in the U.K. rose to 46 million in 2011, a 9.6% increase. He questions the view that depression is a simply chemical imbalance, and believes antidepressants are becoming “a distraction from a wider debate about why we are so unhappy as a society.”

“But even if we accept that antidepressants are effective, a Cochrane review suggests that only one in seven people actually benefits,” said Spence. “Thus millions of people are enduring at least six months of ineffective treatment.”


We’re broadening the diagnosis, treating the symptoms and ignoring the causes.

2 Responses to “Why do we treat mental healthcare so differently than normal healthcare?”

  1. MK Says:

    Giving people anti depressants is a start on helping people get better. The purpose of the pills is to relieve the pain of depression so the patient can start to help themselves. Patients must be willing to accept both kinds of help. It takes a lot of courage to be willing to take the pills and start the healing process. No one can do this alone. Even if you think you can’t be helped, you must be willing to try.

    You are loved. Call us anytime.

  2. Lasivian Says:

    MK I’m not talking about someone who is scared, or clearly clinically depressed. I’m giving an example of someone who has situational depression and even has a clear understanding of the cause. They don’t need courage so much as they need guidance and “training”.

    Sure, there are the times when chemical intervention is needed, but there is no denying there are many times when it is not.

    I’ve talked to several people who have been on mood-altering medications for the better part of their lives, and nothing has been done nor even suggested to help correct the underlying problem(s) that is causing their unhappiness.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Lasivian's small corner of the web.
(Please wipe your browser before entering so you don't track in mud)

Internal Pages:



Si hoc legere scis mimium eruditionis habes

Does your brain hurt yet?

retesostft vntphoim enuni toegtieittyft nece n tiog siheun sec eevd go doyvweelprnnstt ievtg h i tieosddfrntea ytiedtt uryrieyhmhsug rer hieoywle unie tnxeref nfls ettdsiedte fnsiei fdhfZ

(I can't remember how I encrypted this cipher , the first person to crack it gets 10$ via Paypal.)

My Email:

01001010011101010111001101110 10000100000011010000110100101 10010001101001011011100110011 10010000001101101011110010010 00000110010101101101011000010 11010010110110000100000011010 01011011100010000001110000011 01100011000010110100101101110 00100000011100110110100101100 11101101000011101000000110100 00101000001101000010100100110 00110000101110011011010010111 01100110100101100001011011100 10000000110011101101101011000 01011010010110110000101110011 000110110111101101101

How long the USA has been under corporate rule:

Search Posts:


June 2013

External Links:

Things i've read lately:

QR Codes

(Scan these on your cellphone)

My website URL

My E-mail


38 queries. 0.056 seconds